
For the minority of women out there who didn’t see ‘Twilight’, who like their martinis dry – not pink and sweet, and long for the days when men were men – not vampires, werewolves, or personified by a forgettable B-list actor, here are a few movie picks about love, romance, heartbreak, and the infuriating other sex that I think are worth lining up for.
What are your favorites?
1. The Thin Man series: The original ‘Nick’ and ‘Nora’ are the antithesis of those couples who wear matching outfits and pose in their bourgeois marital bliss (eg: Posh and Beck). Instead, they’re the kind of couple you aspire to be a part of and love hanging out with as you regale in their pitch perfect chemistry, genuine mutual affection, and sharp sense of humor. Despite being made in the 30s, Nick and Nora feel strikingly modern with their quick-witted barbs and equal-opportunity martini drinking.
2. Broadcast News: A movie that dared rock the romantic comedy boat and revealed one of the hard truths of mating – which is that you can’t fall in love with someone you don’t respect. It also is one of the most honest movies about career women and the challenge of finding a life partner you adore and respect but also want to have sex with. And sadly, revealed the fallacy of the ‘Himbo or pretty boy’ – which is that much like anything tasty and hot (eg: Shanghainese soup dumplings, french onion soup…), it’s no good the next day.
3. Manhattan: A funny and bittersweet story about how our desire to fall in love can reduce us all into needy, neurotic creatures doomed to repeat our mistakes. Woody Allen’s magic here is his ability to make desperation and a deep lack of self awareness seem really painful and funny at once.
4. Annie Hall: For those who declare that watching two people fall in love is the most boring thing that needs to be reduced to a cliched 2 minute montage, this film will throw that moronic Hollywood screenwriting 101 truism out the window. There’s nothing more real and charming than seeing the central characters obsess and wonder about their appeal to each other. A wonderfully post modern treatment of how men and women continue to simultaneously intrigue and infuriate one another .
5. When Harry Met Sally: A nice 90′s era cousin to ‘Annie Hall’, this film captures so well the differences between the sexes without reducing the characters to ‘Men are From Mars and Women are From Venus’ cliches. Also one of the few romantic comedies where the supporting couple (thanks to a pitch perfect Bruno Kirby and Carrie Fisher) are just as interesting, if not more so than the leads.
6. In the Mood For Love: I give tremendous props to Wong Kar Wai who with the visual magic of Chris Doyle manages to capture the angst and longing of unrequited love and elevate it from banal, pedestrian mooning into a sublime work of art.
7. Bright Star: Jane Campion creates a master work here and delivers a tender love story between poet John Keats and his neighbor Fanny Brawne, with hand crafted period details that are so closely observed and intimate. The film and actors are so nuanced yet vulnerable; with their every blush and ache, we are reminded of the exuberance and fragility of young love. In particular, the power of Keats’ love notes upon Fanny is truly palpable as she hungrily absorbs every word in anticipation of his return (no CGI’d ghost of Keats reciting poetry as he chases Fanny across the English countryside).
8. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind: Beyond the cleverness of the concept and script, the film remains emotionally truthful and resonant. There’s a wonderful, bittersweet element to this movie that reflects that universal urge to not wake up – to stay in that ‘waking dream’ and cling onto the essence of falling in love before it becomes tarnished by the pain of reality.





nice list. every film was about humans… not the living dead or mythical animals
Great choices! I would add off the top of my head: CITY LIGHTS, HIS GIRL FRIDAY, CASABLANCA, THE APARTMENT, UMBRELLAS OF CHERBOURG, SHAMPOO, TOOTSIE, SOME KIND OF WONDERFUL, SAY ANYTHING, MY OWN PRIVATE IDAHO, BEFORE SUNSET/SUNRISE, COMRADES: A LOVE STORY, IL MARE, LOVE ACTUALLY, FAR FROM HEAVEN, many others.
Nice selection of films.
Broadcast News I think is the truest movie about love ever made.
Simon’s favorite movies:
The Hustler
The Godfather
Fight Club
Amadeus
Dead Presidents
Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Battle Royale
Simon, you have a strange definition of what constitutes a love story
Elaine, great blog. You are so right about momvies that reflect real love. So many crappy “romantic comedies” out there that don’t have *&^& to do with real life. Broadcast News made a big impression on me when I saw it as a kid. I need to watch it again.
Momvies? I’m a writer who can’t type and I need work….
In my defense, every movie I chose has a love story. Especially Monty Python and the Holy Grail.
I also remember seeing ‘Broadcast News’ as a kid and being really struck by those simple scenes where Holly Hunter’s character sits and cries. The scenes seemed incongruous with the rest of the film and it wasn’t until I re-watched it as an adult, when I was able to relate and understand the meaning behind those scenes. They weren’t the requisite and literal ‘emotional breakdown’ moments where the heroine is ripped apart by romantic conflict. Instead, I realized the subtext was more profound and universal. Her crying sessions were a primal cathartic release – her way of coping with deep personal conflict which ultimately wasn’t about love and romance, but about a midlife crisis and having to make difficult life choices with integrity.
Great list! I’d also like to add the opening montage sequence in Up. Made me bawl my eyes out.
excellent list of movies. I second Phil’s Umbrellas, and am glad you reminded me of In the Mood fo’ Love. I wasn’t bowled away when I left the theatre, but the more I think about that film, the more I like it. Such LUSH color & clothing, and delicious looking noodles.
& I’ll love When Harry Met Sally forever.